News RSS Feed


On call doc refused to see my child

7:27am Thursday 3rd July 2008

comment Comments (10)   Have your say »

By Alexandra Barham »

A MOTHER who feared her daughter had contracted the killer meningitis bug claims she was refused an emergency home visit by an on-call GP.

Beverley Lewis, of Maylands, was woken in the middle of the night by her sick eight-year-old daughter Krista, who had broken out in a blotchy red rash.

Fearing the worst, the 35-year-old mother-of-three sought medical advice from the Pear Tree Centre, which runs an out-of-hours surgery on the QEII site.

Beverley claims the doctor, now at the centre of an investigation, said Krista's symptoms did not warrant a home-visit and the service was only available for terminally ill or housebound children.

She was then urged not to call an ambulance but to seek treatment at the 24-hour surgery.

Beverley said: "I am a single mum and I don't drive and I had my 11-year-old upstairs asleep.

"I was furious - it put me in an awful position. I had the choice of leaving one child at home unattended or just basically nursing her myself."

Unable to hail a lift to the centre and with no money to afford a taxi, Beverley was forced to care for her sick child with basic medicine, home alone.

She added: "She slept on the sofa and I didn't get to sleep until four in the morning.

"I had to stay up throughout the night and make sure she was okay. I don't mind doing that but at least when a doctor has visited you have that peace of mind.

"Luckily it turned out to be a virus. She had a runny nose, the rash was horrendous and she had breathing difficulties. Knowing what she had now, I would still want her to see a doctor so we know what to do and how serious the illness is."

Beverley has now lodged an official complaint with East and North Hertfordshire Primary Care Trust, the body responsible for monitoring the out-of-hours service in the borough.

A spokeswoman for the PCT, said: "The PCT can confirm that it has received a formal complaint about this case and we are now investigating to find out what happened and to ensure that lessons are learnt. We will contact Ms Lewis as soon as this has been completed.

"Doctors from the out-of-hours service do make home-visits based on clinical needs and we aim to be sensitive to people's personal circumstances.

"This clearly did not happen on this occasion and we are sorry that Ms Lewis appears to have had such an unfortunate experience.

"In the majority of cases we would always encourage parents to bring their child to the out-of-hours centre at the QEII Hospital where there is access to appropriate diagnostic equipment and we can refer to specialist teams if required, something which may be delayed by undertaking a home-visit.

"Public feedback on the local out-of-hours service has been good and in recent discussions with local residents, received favourable comments.

"This makes it even more upsetting to hear of Beverley's experience."

Your Say YourSt Albans

Bob, St Albans says...
1:03pm Thu 3 Jul 08

If Ms Lewis had phoned NHS Direct she would have been asked to describe her daughter's symptoms and would probably have been reassured it was more likely to be a virus and she was not at risk of the "killer meningitis bug".

Now she's throttling the NHS Trust with hundreds of hours work dealing with her complaint. Is this a sensible use of scarce resources?

D, says...
2:06pm Thu 3 Jul 08

I would just like to say there are far too many parents out there who call for help (usually an ambulance!)at the slightest little thing - a babies' first cold or a bump on the head, these people weigh down the already extremely busy nhs, when they should be educating themselves at telling what is life threatening and what is not!

Hassan, Welwyn says...
3:30pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Here we go again...that same expression on the face saying "isn't it awful what happened to me". In these days of sparcity of NHS resources, all that is needed is some common sense, and not calling for help at the slightest sniffle. I agree with the reader above that far too many people call an ambulance for minor problems and then appear in the local paper with that same facial expression when that ambulance takes longer than expected to turn up! If this mother was so concerned, she should have caught a taxi to the local hospital with the child!

Henry, St Albans says...
4:54pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Hassan wrote:
Here we go again...that same expression on the face saying "isn't it awful what happened to me". In these days of sparcity of NHS resources, all that is needed is some common sense, and not calling for help at the slightest sniffle. I agree with the reader above that far too many people call an ambulance for minor problems and then appear in the local paper with that same facial expression when that ambulance takes longer than expected to turn up! If this mother was so concerned, she should have caught a taxi to the local hospital with the child!
I agree with every word. It is high time that the Review stopped giving succour to such drivel. All you have to do is put on a sad expression and spin a sob story and the local rag becomes putty in your hands. Possibly some news might be forthcoming rather than disgraceful whingeing?

Henry, St Albans says...
4:58pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Another point. Although the whingeing mother was 'urged not to call an ambulance', anyone with any sense would do so if they genuinely feared that their child's life was in danger. Therefore medical care was clearly available. Am I alone in thinking that the word 'compensation' is going to enter this debate at some point?

Bob, St Albans says...
5:25pm Thu 3 Jul 08

Wow! Makes a change, other readers agreeing with me, doesn't happen often.

The pitiful facial expressions are stuck on by the paper's photographer - i.e. the more unhappy and disadvantaged you look the greater your chance of getting a free payout, which of course will be another headline story - "Compensation payouts responsible for ward and theatre closures and urgent operations cancelled."


Edward Swannick, St Albans says...
6:04pm Thu 3 Jul 08

60 years ago, when I was a little boy, the National Health Service was born. I was grateful to be given some NHS specs, on the basis that if I hadn't got them from the NHS I wouldn't have had them at all. I doubt that many would be grateful for NHS specs these days. The problem is that if you give people something then they just want more. This woman not only wants medical treatment (which is reasonable) but wants it on her terms at her convenience (which is unreasonable). And when they don't get what they want they complain and complain and complain. If (note the word 'if') compensation ultimately becomes part of this story then shame on the mother for her greed and shame on the Review for publishing such stories.

lee, welwyn says...
9:47am Fri 4 Jul 08

i too have had problems with out of hours doctors,a couple of years ago i went to see my local GP with a bad sore throat,i was told at the time it was tonsillitis,later that evening i was in a very bad way so called the out of hours dr who told me it was "just a sore throat,gargle some dispirin" and refused to come out,6 hours later I was in intensive care fighting for my life with a severe throat condition and a cyst in my throat,so would you all be having a go at this mother if her daughter had been seriously ill and then hospitalised,or worse..may i suggest that some of you think of what the possibilities could have been before coming on here and condemning this woman....and before anyone says what a poor state the NHS are in,I know the conditions and financial restraints they are in,I make a living in hospitals so am in them on a daily basis

Jenny, St Albans says...
11:01pm Tue 8 Jul 08

Here we go again - someone else exploiting their child for a bit of cheap personal publicity. Have you no respect for your child?

Henry, St Albans says...
5:51pm Wed 9 Jul 08

Jenny wrote:
Here we go again - someone else exploiting their child for a bit of cheap personal publicity. Have you no respect for your child?
I absolutely agree. However, as long as there are bottom feeders who persist in taking this approach and local rags who persist in printing this nonsense, the practice will continue. There are a couple of hand-wringers on here but mostly the contributors can see through the whingeing.

Your sayYourSt Albans

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE St Albans & Harpenden Review account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?
Beverley and Krista Beverley and Krista

Hot Jobs

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »